Home
/
Blog
/

Restaurant POS With Online Ordering: How the Options Compare (2027)

Two brown paper takeout bags with order labels on a restaurant counter, with kitchen staff working behind them

A guest orders $50 of food for pickup. On Square's free plan, an online card payment on that order costs you $1.95 in processing. On DoorDash, the same order costs $3 if the guest picks it up, and $7.50, $12.50, or $15 if a Dasher delivers it, depending on the plan you chose. (Square and DoorDash publish those rates.)

Neither number is wrong. They just aren't the same bill. DoorDash says its commission covers the listing, the marketing, the delivery, customer support, and card processing. Square's fee covers card processing.

That's the hard part of online ordering: every system prices the same order differently, and the full number is scattered across a statement, a subscription, and a stack of tablets. If you've outgrown Square or Clover, or you're paying a marketplace more than you expected, here's how the ways to take online orders compare, what each costs, and how to add up your own number.

A POS with online ordering takes the guest's order on your website, app, or Google listing and drops it into the same system your servers use for the dining room. One menu, one set of reports, and nobody retyping tickets. The catch: "built in" doesn't mean free.

What are the ways to take online orders?

There are three, and each one asks you to pay and manage something different.

Marketplace apps. DoorDash and Grubhub list you, market you, and often deliver for you. In exchange you pay a commission on every order, and they bring guests who don't know you yet.

Your POS's own ordering. Orders land in the same system as your dining-room tickets. You pay a software fee, card processing, or both. Square, Toast, Clover, TouchBistro, and Upserve work this way. For the bigger POS picture, see our comparison of 10 restaurant POS systems.

A standalone tool. ChowNow, for example, runs ordering for your own website and apps and says its pricing is commission-free. A connector like Chowly doesn't take orders itself. It pulls marketplace orders into your POS.

Here's how six of them compare on what they publish about cost:

.oo-cmp-wrap{overflow-x:auto;-webkit-overflow-scrolling:touch;margin:0 0 1.25rem;border:1px solid rgba(0,0,0,.15);border-radius:8px}.oo-cmp{border-collapse:collapse;width:100%;min-width:640px;font-size:14px;line-height:1.4;text-align:left}.oo-cmp th,.oo-cmp td{padding:10px 12px;border-bottom:1px solid rgba(0,0,0,.12);vertical-align:top}.oo-cmp thead th{background:#f4f4f2;color:#111;font-weight:600;white-space:nowrap;border-bottom:2px solid rgba(0,0,0,.25)}.oo-cmp tbody th{font-weight:600;white-space:nowrap;background:#fff}.oo-cmp tbody tr:last-child th,.oo-cmp tbody tr:last-child td{border-bottom:0}.oo-cmp tbody tr:nth-child(even) td,.oo-cmp tbody tr:nth-child(even) th{background:#fafaf8}.oo-cmp a{text-decoration:underline}@media(max-width:767px){.oo-cmp-wrap{overflow:visible;border:0;border-radius:0}.oo-cmp{min-width:0;display:block;font-size:15px}.oo-cmp thead{position:absolute;width:1px;height:1px;overflow:hidden;clip:rect(0 0 0 0);white-space:nowrap}.oo-cmp tbody{display:block}.oo-cmp tbody tr{display:block;margin:0 0 14px;border:1px solid rgba(0,0,0,.18);border-radius:8px;overflow:hidden;background:#fff}.oo-cmp tbody tr th,.oo-cmp tbody tr:nth-child(even) th{display:block;white-space:normal;background:#f4f4f2;font-size:16px;padding:12px;border-bottom:1px solid rgba(0,0,0,.18)}.oo-cmp tbody tr td,.oo-cmp tbody tr:nth-child(even) td{display:block;background:#fff;padding:9px 12px;border-bottom:1px solid rgba(0,0,0,.08)}.oo-cmp tbody tr td:last-child{border-bottom:0}.oo-cmp td::before{content:attr(data-label);display:block;font-size:12px;font-weight:600;color:#555;margin-bottom:2px}}

SystemHow you take ordersWhat you pay, per its own pagesUpservePOS's own orderingSee plansSquarePOS's own ordering$0 a month on the free plan. Online card processing is 3.3% + $0.30 on the free plan and 2.9% + $0.30 on Plus and PremiumCloverPOS's own orderingOnline ordering included in restaurant plansDoorDashMarketplace, plus Online Ordering for your own websiteMarketplace: 15%, 25%, or 30% of the order subtotal on delivery (Basic, Plus, Premier) and 6% on pickup. Online Ordering: no commission, but a payment processing fee applies. No monthly fee and no contractChowNowStandalone orderingSays direct orders are commission-free. Plans start at $229 a month on annual billing ($249 monthly), plus 2.95% + $0.29 per transaction and a one-time setup fee of $119 to $499ChowlyConnector for marketplace ordersSays it connects 150+ delivery apps to your POS. No price published; you request a demo

Who delivers your online orders?

Pickup costs you a bag and a shelf. Delivery adds a driver, a clock, and a guest who blames you when the fries show up cold. It's where online ordering math goes wrong, so decide it on purpose.

You have three ways to cover it:

  • Your own drivers. You hire, schedule, and insure them, and you set the zones, the minimums, and the fees.
  • A third-party driver service. You pay per delivery or give up a commission, and a stranger becomes the face of your restaurant for the length of the drive.
  • A marketplace's drivers. DoorDash and Grubhub bring the guest and the driver in one package, and you pay for the package with a commission on every order.

Price each one per delivery before you pick. Say you charge a $5 delivery fee and a driver costs you $9 a run. (Made-up numbers. Use your pay and your mileage.) Every delivery costs you $4 before the food and the box. Raise the fee, set a minimum order, or shrink the zone, and that $4 shrinks with it.

Here's how to turn delivery on without losing money on it:

  1. Draw the zone around Friday night, not Tuesday afternoon. Pick the distance your kitchen can hit when the ticket rail is full.
  2. Set a minimum order high enough to cover the driver.
  3. Pick a fee. A flat fee is easy to explain. A fee that grows with distance is fairer on the long runs.
  4. Add drive time to your prep time. The guest sees one number, so make it one you can hit.
  5. Pack for the trip. Sauces on the side, crispy food vented, cold items away from hot ones.
  6. Decide who fixes problems. Late, cold, or wrong: who calls the guest, and what refund do you offer?
  7. Test it. Order delivery to your own address, from your own phone, during the rush.

How do third-party delivery orders get into your POS?

Picture the pile: one tablet for DoorDash, one for Grubhub, and a POS that knows nothing about either. Every marketplace order gets retyped by hand into your POS, or it stays out of your POS reports.

Three setups cover most restaurants. Tablets and retyping cost the least to start and the most in labor on every order. A connector, like Chowly, pulls marketplace orders into your POS for a software fee. A direct integration between the marketplace and your POS skips the middle step, if your POS vendor supports it. Whichever you pick, ask which marketplaces it covers and whether menus, prices, and sold-out items sync both ways.

The cheapest order is the one nobody types twice.

What does online ordering really cost a restaurant?

Every online order carries some mix of six costs:

  • Commission
  • Software subscription
  • Card processing
  • Delivery fee
  • Hardware or setup
  • The labor of retyping and fixing orders

The first four show up on statements. The last two don't, which is why they get missed.

Add it up with one division: total fees divided by total online sales. Say last month's marketplace statements show $1,800 in fees on $9,000 in sales. Your effective commission rate is 20%. (Those numbers are made up to show the math. Use yours.) Run your own ordering page the same way: processing plus software fees, divided by what the page sold.

Then compare what each fee buys. A 20% marketplace rate that brings a new guest and a driver isn't the same as 20% for a tablet.

What does setup look like?

Setup runs the same steps on most systems. Do them in this order, because each one leans on the one before it.

  1. Clean up the menu. Use item names guests recognize, modifiers that match how the kitchen builds the dish, and photos for your top sellers.
  2. Set your online hours. They don't have to match the dining room. Stop taking orders before the kitchen stops cooking.
  3. Choose your order types: pickup, curbside, delivery, dine-in. Start with fewer, and add one when the last one runs smoothly.
  4. Set prep times, and pad them on Friday and Saturday nights.
  5. Make sure orders print or show up where the kitchen looks. An order the line can't see is a refund.
  6. Place a test order from start to finish. Pay, wait, pick it up, then refund it.
  7. Put the link where guests already look: your website, your Google profile, your social bios, your receipts.

A link nobody can find takes zero orders.

What should you ask any online ordering vendor?

Five questions settle most of it. Ask them in writing.

  1. What's the total cost? Software, per-location fees, commission, processing, and setup, on one page.
  2. How long is the contract, and what happens at renewal?
  3. Do orders reach the POS without anyone retyping them? Ask which POS, and whether menus and sold-out items sync.
  4. Can you set your own hours, order types, and prices for pickup versus delivery?
  5. Can you take your menu and order history with you if you leave?

If a vendor won't answer in writing, that's an answer.

Where Upserve fits

Upserve is an iPad POS built for full-service restaurants, and Upserve Online Ordering runs with it, so orders come into the same system your servers use. You choose which order types to turn on (pickup, delivery, curbside, and dine-in), set the days and hours you take orders, and accept orders ASAP, scheduled, or both. Scheduled orders can be managed from the POS and from Upserve HQ Back Office. You can add promo codes, customize the confirmation messages guests get, and let guests redeem Upserve gift cards, physical or digital.

Delivery works the way the section above assumes: your restaurant handles it. Upserve's Online Ordering terms say restaurants run their own delivery, set their own prices, and set their own cancellation and refund policies.

Upserve's plans and pricing are on its pricing page, and the same advice applies to us: ask for the total in writing. See how Upserve Online Ordering works.

Frequently asked questions

How do I set up online ordering for my restaurant?

Pick your channel first. Then load your menu with its modifiers, set your hours, order types, and prep times, and place a test order from your own phone before you tell anyone. The full seven-step checklist is above.

How much does online ordering cost a restaurant?

It depends on the channel, and the published prices show the spread. DoorDash charges 6% to 30% of the order subtotal, depending on pickup or delivery and the plan. Square charges 2.9% to 3.3% plus $0.30 per online order in processing, with no monthly fee on its free plan. ChowNow's plans start at $229 a month on annual billing, with no commission on direct orders and a processing fee on top. Add delivery fees and setup, then check your own number: total fees divided by total online sales.

Does online ordering have to connect to my POS?

No. You can run marketplace tablets next to your POS. The trade-off is retyping every order, so ask each vendor how orders reach your POS and what the connection costs.

Is it cheaper to take orders directly than through a marketplace?

On a $50 order, yes: $1.95 in Square online processing on the free plan against $3 for DoorDash pickup. The flat $0.30 narrows the gap on small orders, though, and DoorDash says its commission covers listing and marketing, delivery, support, and card processing. An order on your own page doesn't bring you a guest who has never heard of you. Compare effective rates, and count what each fee buys.

What's a good online ordering system for a small restaurant?

It depends on your volume and who delivers. At low volume, a plan with no monthly fee keeps your fees to card processing. A flat monthly plan starts to win once its fee is smaller than the commission you'd otherwise pay on the same orders. Run last month's numbers through the check before you decide.

Go back to that $50 order. Pull last month's marketplace statement, divide the fees by the sales, and you'll know what each door costs you. Then ask each vendor the five questions. Book an Upserve demo.

This post is general information. Fees, plans, and terms change, so confirm current details with each vendor.

Back to Blog